Roger Waters live at Israeli-Palestinian peace village

It wasn’t your average gig promotion. Not many musicians publicise their concerts by turning up in Palestine, dodging press and the army to graffiti a wall with a line from one of their songs, risking arrest and sparking worldwide controversy in doing so.

Still, Roger Waters is not your average musician and this gig hardly needed promoting: originally planned for Tel Aviv, then moved to Neve Shalom after pressure from campaigners, the thousands of fans who have blocked the roads for miles getting here haven’t exactly let it slip their minds.

When Waters takes to the stage to sing classic tracks from Pink Floyd’s The Wall, the songs speak not of individual isolation but racial segregation. The band opened with In the Flesh. During the verse Waters sings “that one in the spotlight he don’t look right to me, get him up against the wall” a giant cheer went up as he followed with the line, “and that one looks Jewish and that ones a coon” confirming that the vast majority of the crowd are young, Jewish Israelis – most Palestinians have neither the money nor the means to attend. The irony of fifty thousand people who live in a state which divides its inhabitants based on their race with a giant wall, singing along to a song attacking racism and discrimination is hard to ignore.

Next up Waters swaps his bass for an acoustic guitar to strum through Mother. Originally written to tell the story of how the actions of his over-protective mother contributed to his feelings of alienation as a young man, the song suddenly serves as a perfect illustration of the relationship between the Israeli administration and its people. “Mother’s going to put all of her fears into you, Mother won’t let anyone dirty get through” echoes the rhetoric behind the need for Israel’s separation wall.

Interestingly Water’s father worked in Palestine between 1934 and 1938. The night before the concert, Waters met with Palestinian musicians at the Edward Said Consortium of Music in East Jerusalem as part of a tour organised by UK anti-poverty group War on Want. He recalled that his mother would receive letters from his Dad telling of the migration of rich Jews into Palestine and their hostile attitude toward the Arab people.

The show is nothing short of what you’d expect from a man associated with some of the biggest and most successful rock concerts in history. The band proceeds to play effortlessly through hits from Wish you were Here, Animals and The Final Cut before taking fifteen minutes to prepare a rendition of Dark Side of the Moon from start to finish. It’s during this performance that the giant video screens serve to treat fans with a truly synaesthetic experience. Heightening the cinematic effect, the sound surrounds the crowd courtesy of small clusters of speakers suspended from giant AVI canes that are eerily reminiscent of the machines used to construct the separation wall in Palestine.

Waters ended up playing in a field in the small Peace Village (Neve Shalom), a project in Arab-Jewish cooperation, after discussions with Palestinian artists like Omar Barghouti,causing him to move from the originally planned venue in Tel Aviv. Some three thousand crew were required to build the venue which housed an estimated fifty thousand fans. Waters agreed to relocate the show in recognition of the daily suffering and humiliation that the Palestinian people face as a result of the Israeli occupation, check points, housing demolitions, settlements and, perhaps most significantly, the illegal separation wall that now surrounds their land.

It was not until the encore that Waters decided to speak out directly against the Occupation, asking Israelis to “tear down the wall!”, before launching into Pink Floyd mega-hit Another Brick in the Wall. His request from the stage reiterated the graffiti Waters wrote on the wall the previous day when visiting Bethlehem with War on Want. Waters is not the only big name to recently denounce the Israeli administration. Sting, who visited Palestinian refugee camps last month called the occupation “an obscenity”.

Whether this generation of Israelis will listen to the pleas of these stars remains to be seen. Recent polls show that 85% of Israeli Jews support the wall. However, Water’s request seemed well received by the crowd, who showed nothing but admiration and excitement throughout the night. Maybe they will be inspired to help bring equal rights to the Palestinians or maybe the most telling song of the night was also the last, as thousands of Israelis unified in singing, I have become comfortably numb. One thing is for sure however, unlike so many other ageing rock legends, Roger still rocks!

---

We Don't Need No Thought Control: War on Want took rock legend Roger Waters and band Belle and Sebastian to the Occupied Territories. See pictures and reports here.

Go to Palestine Homepage: Find out what else you can do, take action and get involved now.